The agencies that close more deals are not better at pitching. They are better at discovery. Here is how to get there.
Most advice about improving discovery calls focuses on tactics. Ask better questions. Use the SPIN framework. Mirror the prospect's language. Those things can help. But they miss the fundamental shift that separates good discovery calls from great ones.
The best discovery calls happen when you are genuinely more interested in understanding the prospect's problem than in selling your solution. That's not a platitude. It changes how you listen, what you ask, and how the prospect responds to you.
When a prospect senses that you are trying to understand them rather than sell to them, they open up. They share the real problems, not the polished version. And real problems are where real deals live.
Fifteen minutes of research before a call is worth more than fifteen extra minutes on the call. When you walk in knowing the prospect's business context, recent challenges, and likely priorities, two things happen:
First, you skip the shallow questions that waste time and signal laziness. Instead of "So tell me about your company," you can say "I saw you just expanded into the UK market. How is that affecting your marketing infrastructure?"
Second, you build trust immediately. The prospect sees that you cared enough to prepare, which makes them more willing to share honestly. Trust compounds from the first minute.
What to research: Company size, growth stage, recent news, the prospect's role and tenure, their LinkedIn activity, competitors, and any obvious challenges for someone in their position.
1. Follow the thread. When the prospect says something interesting, go deeper before moving to your next question. "Tell me more about that." "What does that look like day to day?" "How long has that been going on?" The best insights live two or three layers below the surface answer.
2. Reflect before you respond. When you hear something important, reflect it back before adding your own perspective. "So what I'm hearing is that the real bottleneck isn't lead volume, it's that your team can't convert the leads you already have. Is that right?" This shows you're listening and gives the prospect a chance to correct or deepen.
3. Name the thing they can't name. Prospects often describe symptoms without identifying the underlying pattern. When you can name the pattern, something shifts. "It sounds like your agency has a founder dependency problem. All the relationships, all the trust, all the institutional knowledge lives in one person's head." When you name it, they feel understood. And feeling understood is what drives deals.
Improving your discovery calls is not a one-time fix. It's a feedback loop. Review your calls, identify one thing to improve, practice it for a week, then review again.
The sellers who get dramatically better at discovery all share one habit: they listen to their own calls. Not every call. But enough to see their own patterns. The cringe moments where they talked too much. The questions that opened the prospect up. The transitions that worked or didn't.
Start with your lost deals. Go back to the discovery call for any deal that died in the last 90 days. Listen for the moment it went sideways. That's where the gold is.
Focus on three areas: preparation (15 minutes of research before every call), depth (follow interesting threads two or three layers deep instead of moving to the next question), and review (listen to your own calls regularly to identify patterns). Improvement comes from a feedback loop, not a single tactic.
A good agency discovery call creates enough trust that the prospect shares their real problems, goes deep enough to reach root causes rather than surface symptoms, and ends with specific committed next steps. It should feel like a collaborative conversation, not an interrogation or a pitch.
Prepare thoroughly so you skip shallow questions, follow threads instead of jumping to the next question, reflect back what you hear before responding, and name patterns the prospect has not been able to articulate themselves. Trust builds fastest when the prospect feels genuinely understood.
The specific questions matter less than how you follow up on the answers. Start with open questions about the prospect's current situation and goals, then go deeper on whatever feels most charged or interesting. "Tell me more about that" and "How long has that been going on?" are more valuable than any scripted question list.
Paste a recent transcript into Call Lab. Get a diagnostic that shows exactly where you are strong and where you are losing momentum.
← Back to Call Lab